Ajouter un commentaire

Chermany

Recommander cet article

Chinese Demand meets German Supply

“Konjunkturaufschwung” and “Wachstumsboom” are words that haven’t been heard in Germany for quite some time. However, after the Bundesbank posted an impressive second quarter GDP growth of 2.2 % (the strongest since re-unification in 1990), many Germans are now more optimistic than ever about their economic future. Yet, where does this growth derive from ? The answer is simple : China. We’ve all heard of Chimerica, but in the post-financial crisis landscape, another economic axis is coming to the forefront : Chermany. Indeed, Germany is increasingly finding that the way to economic recovery lies within demand from the Middle Kingdom. This article will analyze what a booming Chinese economy will mean for Europe’s economic powerhouse.


Hungry for German goods

Walking on the streets of Shanghai and Beijing, one is quick to notice that the newly-affluent in China drive Audi, Mercedes or BWM. After almost a decade of unprecedented growth, China’s emerging middle class is splurging on European goods like never before. This phenomenon has found its way into the highest circles. Indeed, Audis have even become something of a “cadre-car” for communist officials who strive for comfort and style but do not want to appear “flashy” while driving a BMW or a Mercedes. The four rings are quickly replacing the red flags of the domestically produced Hongqi government sedans of Deng and Mao’s time.

This new-found fondness of German products has translated into a renewed vigour for the German economy. Having previously established strong positions in Asia and benefiting from prudent cost-cutting measures, German firms are capitalizing on the new Kauflust of the mainlanders. Daimler, Audi and BMW are headed towards record profits this year. All reported spectacular operating profit margins of more than 9% in their luxury automotive sector in the second quarter, with Daimler reporting that 20-30% of its sales growth comes from China.

The Chinese are not just buying cars. In areas such as consumer goods, where Siemens and Bosch have long enjoyed favourable reputations as higher-quality, longer-lasting alternatives to domestic brands such as Haier and Robam, the Chinese are increasingly splurging on German-made products. Siemens has reported an €89 billion order backlog last month, the highest in its 163-year history.

Growing Chinese demand has also had positive effects on suppliers. Grammer, a leading German manufacturer for car seats and armrests increased its sales by 30% in the first half-year of 2010 to around €445 million.

Amidst dynamic growth in both countries, unpleasant episodes such as BASF boss Jürgen Habrecht and Siemens boss Peter Loescher’s direct criticisms at Prime Minister Wen Jiabao about unfair Chinese business practices during Chancellor Merkel’s July state visit to Beijing seem all but forgotten.

A story of optimism

Berlin has always appreciated the potential of the Chinese market and has been very keen to promote a deepening German-Chinese relationship. The Shanghai Expo capped off a three-year project first announced by Chancellor Merkel and Chinese Premier Wen in August 2007, aimed at promoting closer ties between Germany and China. The project, called “Germany and China – Moving Ahead Together” consisted of 600 events and activities, lasted from autumn 2007 to present, involving 130 million people in important urban centres such as Nanjing and Guangzhou.

German firms have mirrored this interest. Alone Daimler is investing around €3 billion in the construction of new plants over the next few years and hoping to drastically increase its sales volume. If BMW’s performance is any indication of what the future might bring, then it certainly looks good for German carmakers. The Bavarian firm’s sales grew around 82% in July, selling 13 852 vehicles.

The often criticized German model of export-dominated growth is –at least at the moment- paying off. Publications from within Germany and abroad have recently commented that Germany is single-handedly pulling the EU out of the slump. There is some merit to this contention. While Germany posted impressive numbers in the second quarter, across the channel, the Bank of England lowered its growth forecasts, citing tight credit conditions and government spending cuts. France, Spain and Portugal all posted GDP growth rates of between 0.2-0.9 percent with unemployment in Spain hovering around 20%. It seems that Germany has retained its place as the star-performer in Europe.

In many ways Germany is looking eastward to diversify its portfolio. One remembers that before the financial crisis Germany ran a large current-account surplus while selling freely to other euro-zone countries, allowing them to run up large debts. The common currency hid dangers that would have normally been revealed by an exchange-rate crisis. When recession finally came, it meant that the impact was much worse on Germany. Demand slumped in the euro-zone, where growth had been based on consumer spending. A collapse in exports and investment meant that German GDP fell by 7% from its peak.

To be wary or not to be wary

Should the growing expectations that the German economy can rely on China for retained and constant growth be viewed with scepticism ? There are already some worrying indications that demand in China is slowing. The China Association of Auto Manufacturers (CAAM) has observed that growth (compared to the same time last year) in new car purchases have slowed from 19% in June to 14% in July. First dealerships on the mainland have already dropped their prices to retain sales-volumes.

There also other signs that the Chinese market is showing cracks around the edges. Beijing has already stepped in to slow the overheating real estate market to prevent the formation of a property bubble. Also, recent labour disputes in coastal factories have had international reverberations. One can only imagine the effects to any disruptions in the ‘social contract’ between Beijing and the massive migrant worker populations, who are the backbone of China’s economic growth.

The German economic machine lives and dies with its export industry and thus is vulnerable to major shifts in its trade relationships. With an industrial sector that accounts for around 30% of its labour force and is responsible for 49% of its revenues, one can only imagine the effects if demand for German finished goods in the emerging markets were to slow. Considering that demand in the home market is expected to slow due to wide-ranging consolidation measures enacted this June, one draws the conclusion that Germany is now more than ever dependent on emerging markets.

Conclusion

There are several kinks in the Chinese-German trade relationship that have the potential to affect this cross-continental symbiosis. One issue on the horizon is the continued argument over China’s Market Economy Status (MES). As is well known, the EU has measures against some 49 Chinese products as well as anti-dumping duties targeted against the mainland. For Beijing, the issue is not merely economic but also political. It considers the lack of China’s MES status as motivated by protectionism and ultimately deems it a “loss of face”. This line of argument is especially explosive in China, where any sort of “mistreatment” of the Middle Kingdom by the west invokes inflammatory memories of the unequal treaties of the Opium Wars.

Even so, there is little reason to believe that the “Chermany” phenomenon is not here to stay. Despite some worries about the Chinese market, it is largely stable. Beijing has repeatedly shown willingness for concerted and prudent action against any sort of economic destabilization and has made it perfectly clear that it wants to foster the current rate of double-digit GDP growth (10.3% year on year in the second quarter compared with 11.9% in the first quarter). German firms are in China to stay too. Volkswagen has long cited China as its “second home market”, although it really is its first, considering that VW has sold more cars in China than in Germany for some time now.

With the slowly appreciating RMB, domestic demand is only expected to rise in China. The mainlanders’ stronger purchasing-power has translated into more consumers spending on luxury goods which has, according to chief HSBC Trinkaus economist Stefan Schilbe, meant more demand for German goods.

For China, the success of the Chermany phenomenon has even wider ramifications. Having recently overtaken Japan as the second-biggest economy in the world while its citizens enjoy a growing standard of life, many have argued that China provides a viable alternate governance model for African and Latin American states. The “Beijing Consensus” seems to have validated itself. Tight government control infused with a generous dose of market capitalism ensured that it took only a short thirty years from Deng Xiaoping’s first market-reforms to result in brim-full BMW and Mercedes dealerships in Chinese cities.

Headline Picture : flickr.com


Recommander cet article
reagir   Imprimer   envoyer par mail   Auteurs
Espace réactions (3)
ds Ajouter un commentaire
Benjamin
7 septembre 2010
14:49
Chermany

Some basic figures are missing which would help putting things in perspective. German exports to China only represent about 4.5% of the value of total German exports. You focus on cars, which at present only account for 16% of German exports to China (that is, 0.7% of total German exports). Claiming that German growth derive from (car) exports to China is therefore a bit of a shortcut. (Besides, it is always good remembering that trade only accounts for part of the growth, even in an export-led economy like Germany).

However, I do understand that you are trying to underline an indeed interesting trend. Here you have a point : from 1980 to 2008, German exports to China rose by an annual 13% on average compared to 6.5% for total German exports. The link between the evolution of Chinese consumption habits and demand for German products is also worth analysing. But your conclusions should be more careful.

ds Réagir à ce commentaire
Zhong
7 septembre 2010
23:43
Chermany

Thank you for your comments Benjamin.

The point of the article is to highlight that Germany’s recent growth in 2010 Q2 has been mainly driven by growing demand from emerging markets, with China being one of the main markets that German manufacturers are concentrating on. You cannot deny that 2010 Q2 growth in Germany has been heavily attributed to countries outside of the Euro-zone. Statistics indicate that exports to non-Euro-zone states increased 37.3% compared to 22% to the Euro-zone in August, compared to July. I do not contend the fact the Europe is still the biggest target market for German export goods but it is interesting to note that it lost 2.5% of its “market-share” to China last year. From having computed the Destatis data myself recently I conclude that your “4.5% of total export” numbers must be derived from the 2009 data-set (from my computation it’s actually around 5%), I do believe that China will account for slightly more in 2010, considering the role it had in the recent growth. One of the main stories is of course German car exports to China, which have increased 170% from the same time last year, a fact celebrated by domestic publications such as the FTD and Handelsblatt.

Certainly growth is not only derived from the sales of BMWs and Mercedes in the Middle Kingdom, however I also mentioned that German household brands such as Siemens are enjoying a remarkable year so far as their orders have sky-rocketed from Chinese demand.

Thank you also for mentioning that trade only accounts for part of growth. This is of course true. However, the 2.2% GDP growth in 2010 Q2 have indeed been largely attributed to trade and investment -as you know, the two are closely linked and hence often form two sides of the same coin-. (Growth breakdown : 0.8% from Foreign trade, 0.8% from Gross capital investment, 0.3% from private consumption, 0.1% from public consumption and 0.1% from inventories).

And I am not sure what you mean about needing to be careful about the conclusion. With China very much needing to maintain at least a close to double-figure growth rate, it means that demand will be there for German products and investment in the foreseeable future. German firms have realized this. BASF and Siemens have just opened up new operations in China in anticipation of this potential. As mentioned in the conclusion, firms like VW will continue to invest in China and try to capitalize on China’s consumption appetite.

I also maintain that economic vigour has a place in political discourse, especially in China. “The Beijing Consensus”’s relevance is partly derived out of the economic successes of China. So Chermany’s ability to provide Chinese consumers with desired goods will necessarily feed into the legitimacy of the party, which derives more and more authority not out of communist ideals but out of its ability to provide China’s 1.3 billion people with an escalating standard of living.

Benjamin
8 septembre 2010
10:37
Chermany

Thank you for your answer. I am happy with all the arguments you give.

I was mostly reacting to your introducing statement : « where does this growth derive from ? The answer is simple : China », which of course can be excused as a journalistic simplification. I do not object to the substance of your article, on the contrary, but I didn’t find it as clear as your answer to my comment. I was expecting to read in your main article the figures you actually give in your answer : on export growth, market shares, etc. I have nothing to add ; I even thank you for figures I wasn’t aware of. I didn’t know about the 170% increase of German car exports to China - I heard about the good performance, but this is really impressive. I am also glad you talk about trade and investment ; that’s a good point.

As regards your more political conclusion (which I wasn’t referring to), without claiming any expertise on China I can only agree that economic performance is key to any regime’s legitimacy. But do you think that in the medium to longer term, the current governance model will be able to ’redistribute’ the fruits of economic prosperity in such a way that it meets the expectations of an ever-growing middle class, and to tackle the challenge of growing social disparities ? This is an open question.

I hope to read more on trade and economic issues on this website in the future.

ds Réagir à ce commentaire
ds Ajouter un commentaire
Business, social affairs, companies
The UK faces its first serious financial crisis at the beginning of the 21st century. One way to solve the problem would be to take steps towards (...)
The European Commission intervened and found the necessary conditions for opening a formal enquiry relating to the State Aid (...)

Autres langues de cet article :

Das « Chermany »-Phänomen

Auteurs

Zhong ZHONG CHEN

As a Chinese-Canadian who has lived, studied and worked in Europe, North America and Asia, Zhong has always been fascinated by transatlantic as well as European-Asian relations. He completed his undergraduate studies with a Combined Honours (...)

On the internet

German Exports, Investment Drove Record Second-Quarter Growth, Data Show
Bloomberg

China.org.cn
China still striving for 'market economy' status from EU

Agence France Presse
EU's Ashton urges China on trade
Last comment

I think you have raised a very good topic that has generated good discussion among the users of your site. it helped me learning a lot

binder91 on Does the EU have anything to do (...) | 2 February 2012, 15:25 (26)

ce qui est totalement au point et il est de donner l’explication complète de subject.thank vous.

sink kitchen stainless on Does the EU have anything to do (...) | 2 February 2012, 11:01 (26)

Vraiment, l’affichage fantastique! Merci pour le partage. Je ne accepter un renfort des questions pour vous, donc je vais assister à votre e-mail et les envoyer par courriel anon si cela vous (...)

Telefonsex on Does the EU have anything to do (...) | 30 January 2012, 08:55 (26)

Really wonderful piece of information and I appreciate it that you share something humorous and reader can relate to this,

aleximan25 on Does the EU have anything to do (...) | 27 January 2012, 05:46 (26)

I want to express my admiration of your writing skill and ability to make viewer, read the whole thing to the end. I’d like to read more of your blogs and to discuss my views with you. I will be (...)

seo forum on Does the EU have anything to do (...) | 25 January 2012, 20:05 (26)

Who's been tweeting?
Facebook

The Jean Monnet Centre of Excellence of the University of Roma Tor Vergata, in partnership with Eurosduvillage group, is organizing the eighth edition of the Jean Monnet Summer Seminar a high level seminar on the functioning of the European Union addressed to graduate and Phd students as well as young civil servants. The seminar include two teaching modules lasting one week. The first module (4-8 July) will analyze the decision making process of the European Union while the second one (11-15 July) the foreign policy of the European Union. For more information and registration go to: http://www.eusummerseminar.uniroma2.it/

Jean Monnet Summer Seminar

Politics
Economy
Media & Society
Green business
Internal Affairs
External Affairs
Institutions & Brussels Bubble
United Kingdom
EU 27
Rest of Europe
World
© Groupe Euros du Village 2010 | Legal notice | Site réalisé avec SPIP | Technical realisation and design : Media Animation & Euros du Village France